Lunæ vs. The Eye of the Ocean: Which Series Should You Collect?

Quick Answer

If you prefer celestial navigation and ancient mysteries, start with the Eye of the Ocean series, especially Astra Polaris. If you're drawn to quirky, character-driven decks with a lighter tone, the Lunæ series (like The Dude) offers more playful storytelling. Choose based on your aesthetic: epic archaeological lore vs. whimsical odd fellows.

Stockholm17 has built a reputation for intricate, story-driven playing cards that double as collectible art. Two of their most beloved series—Lunæ and The Eye of the Ocean—offer very different experiences. While Lunæ focuses on quirky characters and Victorian charm, The Eye of the Ocean immerses you in a nautical archaeological quest. But how do you decide which series to collect?

This comparison breaks down the key differences—art style, theme, and collectibility—using the actual decks available. Whether you're a seasoned collector or just starting, you'll know exactly which series fits your taste and budget.

Art and Theme: Quirky Characters vs. Epic Lore

The Lunæ series, as seen in decks like The Dude and Odd Fellows: Uncle Tibia, embraces a whimsical, character-driven approach. Each deck introduces a new odd fellow—a laid-back penguin magician or a spiced-bone-brewing uncle—with fully custom illustrations that burst with personality. The art style is more cartoonish and humorous, appealing to collectors who enjoy storytelling with a wink.

In contrast, The Eye of the Ocean series is grand and mysterious. Decks like Astra Polaris and Malakim Gilded draw inspiration from celestial navigation and ancient ruins. The tuckboxes are designed to mimic weathered monuments, and the card backs feature intricate metallic foils and antique map motifs. This series feels like unearthing a relic, perfect for those who love deep lore and visual grandeur.

• Lunæ decks are lighter in tone, with playful characters and bold colors.
• Eye of the Ocean decks use muted, antique tones with metallic accents for an epic feel.

Collectibility and Rarity

Both series offer limited print runs, but the Eye of the Ocean is positioned as a premium collectible. The Astra Polaris deck, for instance, won Deck of the Year 2022 at 52+Joker and Portfolio52, which boosts its desirability. Its unique tuckbox shows gilded edges with an antique gold pattern, making it a centerpiece for any collection.

Lunæ decks, while still collectible, are more accessible. The Dude is a collaboration with Penguin Magic and comes at a lower price point. Odd Fellows: Uncle Tibia is the first official P52-branded project, adding a niche appeal. If you're looking for a fun entry into Stockholm17's world without the higher cost, Lunæ is a great starting point.

• Eye of the Ocean decks often have award-winning designs and higher resale potential.
• Lunæ decks are more affordable and easier to find, but still hold value for character lovers.

Price and Value

Price is a major factor. The Eye of the Ocean decks, like Astra Polaris at $22.50, are priced higher due to premium finishes and complex tuckboxes. Malakim Gilded at $12.50 offers a more budget-friendly entry into the series but still delivers the luxurious feel with metallic foils.

Lunæ decks are generally cheaper: The Dude costs $9.00, and Odd Fellows: Uncle Tibia is $12.50. If you're on a tight budget or want to collect multiple decks, Lunæ gives you more bang for your buck. However, the Eye of the Ocean series offers a more immersive experience that justifies the premium for many collectors.

• Eye of the Ocean: $12.50–$22.50 per deck, with some bundles like Puzzle Master at $125.50.
• Lunæ: $9.00–$12.50 per deck, making it easier to collect a full set.

The Trade-offs: Lunæ vs. Eye of the Ocean

• Art Style: Lunæ decks are whimsical and character-driven, with bold, cartoonish illustrations. Eye of the Ocean decks are epic and antique, with metallic foils and intricate patterns. Choose Lunæ for playful art; choose Eye of the Ocean for serious, museum-like aesthetics.
• Storytelling: Lunæ tells individual character stories with humor. Eye of the Ocean builds a continuous archaeological narrative across decks, with a novel and quest components. If you love deep lore and interconnected stories, Eye of the Ocean is more rewarding.
• Budget and Collectibility: Lunæ decks are more affordable ($9-$12.50), making it easier to collect multiple. Eye of the Ocean decks are pricier ($12.50-$22.50) but have higher collectible status and potential resale value. Set a budget: Lunæ for quantity, Eye of the Ocean for quality and investment.

Key Decks at a Glance

• Astra Polaris - The Eye of the Ocean: Deck of the Year 2022 at 52+Joker and Portfolio52. Unique tuckbox mimics ancient ruins, showing gilded edges with antique gold pattern. 56 cards printed by Cartamundi. This is a top-tier collectible with award-winning design, ideal for serious collectors who want a centerpiece deck.
• Malakim Gilded - The Eye of the Ocean: Part II of the Eye of the Ocean series (2024). Features metallic foils, detailed illustrations, and antique map motifs. A more affordable way to own a gilded deck from the series, offering the same luxurious feel without the premium price of Astra Polaris.
• The Dude - Standard: Collaboration with Penguin Magic. Features a laid-back penguin magician. 56 cards, poker size, 100% custom illustrated. Perfect for Lunæ fans who enjoy quirky characters and want a unique, playful deck at an entry-level price.
• Odd Fellows: Uncle Tibia: First official P52-branded project. Character is a 'notorious blend of spiced bones brewed with victorian tombstones'. A must-have for Odd Fellows collectors due to its P52 connection, offering a distinctive blend of humor and macabre art.

Which Series Fits You?

Best for

• Collectors who love intricate, award-winning art and epic nautical lore.
• Those who enjoy immersive storytelling and want a deck with a premium feel.

Not for

• Budget-conscious collectors who prefer playful, character-driven decks and lower price points.
• Those who dislike darker, antique themes and prefer brighter, humorous art.

Ultimately, the choice between Lunæ and The Eye of the Ocean comes down to your personal taste. If you're drawn to whimsical characters and affordable fun, start with Lunæ. If you want a prestigious, visually stunning collection that tells a grand story, invest in The Eye of the Ocean. Both series showcase Stockholm17's creativity, so you can't go wrong—just pick the one that speaks to you.